Thursday, March 12, 2009

Credible Vs. Non-Credible Sources

http://www.buzzle.com/articles/types-of-dances-and-different-dancing-styles.html
I know it is a non-credible source because:
1. It has a ".com" web domain-meaning that anyone could have purchased it.
2. There is no clear author. On this site anyone can sign up and become an author.
3.The focus of this site is not targeted toward dancing and health. There are many subjects that deal with helpful and harmful things to the body.
4. But this site does have a list of related articles and sources.
5. There were no advertising on this page.



http://www.we-relax.com/relaxation-related/the-health-benefits-of-dancing.htm
I know it is a non-credible source because:
1.It has a ".com" web domain-meaning that anyone could have purchased it.
2.This page has advertisiments on the side which shows it is a non-credible site.
3. The focus was on relaxation for the body using dancing.
4. It has more than one author.
5. It has a list of related aticles.

http://www.shira.net/bookrvws/bd4health.htm
I know this is a credible source because:
1. This site ends in ".net" which means it is a network.
2. There isn't any advertisment on this page.
3. The focus of this page is toward belly dancing and how it helps the body.
4. There is one author and her name is Shira.
5. There is a list of all the classes and instructions on how to do belly dancing. She has links to show her sources of her knowledge for belly dancing and health.
I know this is a credible source because:
1. This site ends in ".edu" which shows it is a unviersity.
2.There are no advertisments on this page.
3. There focus was toward dancing helping someone remember information, which helps the brain in the long run.
4. The authors were kept to a minium.
5.There is a list of other related articles and sources at the bottom of this page.

2 comments:

  1. You go, Bebe. You went ahead and did all five qualities, instead of just three. Whichever college you go to is going to be lucky to have you.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I hate to break this to you, but anyone can buy .net as well. The type of domain really doesn't have any relevance as to whether or not something is credible, really. The only exception is .edu, and even then, any student at the school can make a website on the school's domain, which will not automatically make it a good source. Advertising, unfortunately, is everywhere, on all sorts of sites (most large sites that get a lot of hits cannot afford to pay for all that bandwidth without advertising).

    What you really want to look for is a list of sources and references; these can be of any sort although the best are journals, published works, and academic materials (the worst being other websites, though this doesn't necessarily mean it's not good info). Check out the bottom of any Wikipedia article and you'll see the kind of sources and documentation meant to show something is valid.

    ReplyDelete